Shel Israel, co-author of Naked Conversations, currently working on his Global Neighbo(u)rhoods project, is conducting a survey for SAP. I've answered some of his questions from this survey that he's posted on LinkedIN. Recently, Shel has invited the world to "roll their own" and participate in his survey on their on own blogs. Here's my take.

1. From where you sit in the world, how has social media changed your life? How about the lives of your other family members?
   1. In the world, I sit along the Pacific Coast of San Mateo County in Northern California, about 17 miles south of San Francisco and 25 miles away from Silicon Valley, in a community made up of four towns called the Coastside, comprised of a disproportionate number of artists, craftsfolk, techies and entrepreneurs.
   2. I've been fascinated by science and the application of science through technology and engineering, and as portrayed by science fiction, since a neighbor, a retired school teach, gave me a Tom Swift, Jr. book when I was in first grade. And I live in an area of the world that shares this fascination. I wouldn't say that social media has changed my life, it is merely one more means of communication that I use in both my business and personal affairs.
   3. That answer is rather meaningless though, in that we haven't defined "social media". Terms are bandied about and hyped, such as Web2-dot-oh, read-write web, and live web. I'm not going to attempt to define these terms, nor give an accurate history of the development of the Internet and the World Wide Web. In broad strokes, the Internet developed to provide more robust and survivable communications than what is available through circuit based networks, such as your POTS. The web was conceived as a more effective means of exchanging information, based in digital files, over the Internet. With the introduction of a graphical web user interface, the web quickly grew into a vehicle for transactions as well as communications. Filling in forms became a normal part of using the web, and electronic bulletin boards, such as The Well and Compuserve, migrated to the web. So, really, since it's early days, the web has been two-way. What is new, is the adoption of blogs and podcasts by a larger percentage of the general population, the rise of Wikipedia, and some other niche use of wikis, the evolution of portal and collaboration technology into online networking tools, and of course, the hype surrounding all of these.
   4. I don't mean to downplay
      1. Facebook becoming a platform,
      2. podcasts on every digital media player and computer,
      3. the rise of blogs,
      4. social bookmarking,
      5. rating and ranking news & opinion articles,
      6. online video,
      7. using the contacts of the folk in your address book to get more contacts,
      8. two-way communications with customers and vendors and partners - beyond focus groups,
      9. nor the whole idea of putting media creation into everyone's hands for life-tracking
      What I do mean to say is that what we're seeing today is simply another step in the way in which we communicate, and as have other transportation and communication and entertainment/media technology, these new technologies composing "social media" are just another step towards expanding our horizons. That said, it is still a long way from being a universal phenomenon. To answer the final part of this question...
   5. The "killer app" of the Internet was email, and this is still the app that the majority of my family, friends and business associates use. Web browsing is next; photo sharing comes after browsing - all on different sites, none using flickr; instant messaging comes and goes in popularity - likely because of the incompatible platforms; and texting from a mobile isn't common, nor is VoIP. My parents [late 70's, early 80's] use email and IM almost interchangeably, just understanding that they can get in touch with other family members using those tools. My peer group [age 50 +10/-15 years of age] use email, some with gusto, and others not so much; one or two enjoy - and then email - the videos found on the web. The younger generation doesn't seem all that different. My extended family and old school chums are mostly in Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware, and two small groups in Colorado. I haven't found any family members on LinkedIN. I dont' know of anyone in my family that writes a blog, nor uses a feed reader. This is also true of the old school chums. And, actually, it is true of my nearby friends and business associates, except those, like Shel, that I met through blogging, and one fellow with whom I worked 22 years ago, is now a good friend, that I convinced to start blogging last October, who wrote several entries that month, and none since. Contrast this with the fact that I literally don't know anyone who doesn't, however reluctantly, use email.
2. From where you sit in the world, how do you think your personal and business lives will change over the next five years? Hw about for the rest of your family?
   1. I've already told you where I sit in the world. I've been pushing for the use of collaboration software instead of email for a long time now. I think that sending a large attachment in email, be it a document, a picture, a video, or whatever, is the height of idiocy. But using an ftp client was too hard for most people. Even WebDAV or sites, including one that I first started using 11 years ago, that allow one to upload a file and then email a link to intended recipient(s) of that document, spreadsheet, presentation, picture or video, simply don't find favor with those recipients. I have found that many people ignore requests that come through LinkedIN, but will respond positively to a direct email requesting the same thing.
   2. I would like to think that within 10 years, other Internet based tools, the read-write web, social media, life-tracking, and accessing these web tools from your mobile device or entertainment appliance or coffee table surface will become as common as email is today. I have my doubts though. eMail is very easy to use, and is very platform agnostic. Until social media, social networking, photo sharing, tagging, social bookmarks, social news aggregation, virtual environments, citizen journalism, life-tracking, what-have-you is as easy, interoperable and reliable as email has become, my family, friends and colleagues won't be using them.
3. What do you feel are the ascending social media tools and which are descending?
   1. While it may seem that I'm coming off as a Ludite here, let me take a different tack on this answer. I truly do believe in these technologies, and hope for a profound impact from the globalization that started with the Silk Road and Spice Routes of 2000-to-4000 years ago. One blog that we write is about management of distributed work and toys and tools and technologies that come together for the TeleInterActive Lifestyle. after all. Our activity has become less on that blog due to the frustration we feel in the adoption, at all levels, of these new social media and related technologies for communication and collaboration. Here's how I answered this question when Shel posted it on LinkedIN.
   2. The social media tools that are on the rise are SaaS or self-hosted open source applications using tagging, rankings, bookmark sharing, dashboards, microformats and workflow for internal and external community building around businesses or around processes, programs or projects within a business. Such open source applications include blogs, wikis, CMS, ECM, online project management and roll-your-own versions of del.icio.us.
   3. The future may be tending towards using virtual environments [open source versions of the Second Life server, or the recently open sourced Second Life client] as a platform both for collaboration among distributed workers and data visualization.
   4. Hosted blogs such as from blogger/blogspot [almost completely overrun by splogs] are on the decline. Other efforts such as building personal or group communities using hosted wikis or community-building tools such as PeopleAggregator are either yet to take off, or have died ablooming. I think that these tools, allowing folks or businesses or groups to form their own online communities for work and play will gain traction, if they become, as stated above, easy, interoperable and reliable.
4. The folks at SAP are particularly interested in social media's impact on the global enterprise as well as small to medium-sized corporations. Do you have any knowledge or advice for them?
   1. The impact on enterprises, whether government or commercial, large or small, has been slow to come about. People still have a tendency to turn to email before eRoom, a blog or a wiki. I've already mentioned that people will respond to a request made through email that was ignored when made through LinkedIN. We are slowly seeing some changes, but not very quickly. We can all see the results of large consumer-facing companies' use of blogs and virtual environments for either marcomm, PR, analyst briefings or and genuine efforts to engage their customers. As blogs, and sites like MySpace and Facebook, accelerate the harmful or helpful impact of urban myth and personal recommendations on an organization's reputation, and as those organizations learn to respond and control those impacts, we will see greater utilization of social media by large corporations and government entities. I don't think there has been as much as a general uptick in the use of other types of social media at the corporate level, and it's difficult to gauge the impact on the corporation of the uses individuals are making of social media. For example, if LinkedIN didn't exist, would company A have been able to hire that great new employee. Can a company truly know, understand or learn from a viral message circulating through Facebook or other community site(s)?
   2. Three years ago, we started an hosting service, in addition to our professional services, to provide small businesses that either never had, or were disappointed by, their Web presence with access to these new applications. We provide a consultative experience, learning about their business, selecting tools that might help them extend their relationships from the physical world into new areas. For the most part, the only service, beyond email, that was exciting to our early customers, was a web based content management system. Such systems separate the structure, presentation, and look of a site from the site management and content. They provide fairly easy, web-based WYSIWYG editors. However, all of those web sites are the same as when we helped with the first postings. Recently, we have seen interest in blogging from new customers who have read a couple of blogs and want to see if it can help their business. We don't yet know how this will go, but there's hope.
5. Do you have any interesting case studies of unique uses of social media?
   1. Our professional services provide strategic direction, architecture & modeling, and project management for data management & analytics programs. Such programs may be data warehousing or business intelligence, or may include extending data collection, data flow and information exchange with remote workers, the public, or through mobile devices. We also focus on open source strategies, both for implementation of these programs, and in helping entrepreneurial firms reach a decision on going open source. Our customers include large, international firms, government agencies, SME growing companies, non-profit groups and Universities. I can't offer specific case studies here without violating NDA. I will describe how we've been using open source software to enhance communication & collaboration among program and project members. The first thing that we do after contract award is to host, or set up a customer-internal server, with b2evolution, MediaWiki and dotProject.
   2. The b2evolution blogging engine provides multi-author, multi-language, multi-blogs under one installation, as well as workflow for the posts. We set up blogs for various aspects of the project, and make appropriate members authors and/or publishers for each blog. In addition, each team member gets their own blog. The blogs are used to gather, document and prioritize everything from user desires and current technical realities, to project scope and issue resolution.
   3. Wikis are a great way to write, on the web, a book, magazine, white paper or any type of formal document. MediaWiki is the open source wiki software behind Wikipedia, and other great wiki projects on the web. You may or may not have noticed, but for each article within Wikipedia, there is a tab for discussion about that article. Also, one installation of MediaWiki can be divided into "projects" or "books". We set up a "book" for each project documentation deliverable, such as the Strategy Document, Project Charter, Test Plan(s), Functional, System & Design specifications, manuals and various reports. We decide, with the customer, who may be an author for each "book" and who may only comment in the discussion areas. Any given "book" may have one or many authors,and generally, all members of the project team may comment.
   4. dotProject is open source, online project & task management, which provides very good tools for schedule & issue tracking, as well as file exchange and other collaboration tools.
   5. Other tools that we might use include online survey creation and analysis software, and bookmark sharing. We are also investigating the use of Alfresco for enterprise content management. Alfresco provides many of the same capabilities as Documentum and Sharepoint, as well as means to plug in our blogs, wikis and other collaboration tools providing an instant and very robust knowledgebase and compliance tool. Adding on some of the open source data analytics and reporting tools that we study, such as JasperSoft, Pentaho and SpagoBI, and configuration control such as subversion, and we provide project social networking among all partners, inside and outside the customer.
6. What social media tools do you use? Which are your favorites? Why?
   1. I blog, using b2evolution, under the TeleInterActive Press, on the TeleInterActive Lifestyle, Open Source Solutions [primarily for data management & analytics] and my personal blog, where this post is published, on pretty much anything I feel like. I get more hits on my recipes than on anything else.
   2. I use a feed reader, and prefer a "storage" type to a "river-of-news" type of feed reader. The reason for this is that there are folk, whose opinion I value, who don't blog often. I'm also not glued to my read reader, so an important event that happened a few hours ago, but is news to me, is more interesting than some trivia that passes by this moment. I read old school media as well as blogs of all types. I subscribe to several hundred feeds but read only an handful daily, and another handful on some days. Whatever piques my interest, or fills a current need.
   3. I use LinkedIN. I've reconnected with some colleagues from past jobs. Primarily, I've found it to be a good way to reinforce new meetings. Inviting someone that you just met, who is already a member of LinkedIN, seems to be a very good way to cementing that relationship. Much better than a follow-on email or phone call. As I've mentioned before though, attempts to get recommendations or introductions by using LinkedIn's tools have failed, whereas emailing that same person directly with the same request, works. Thus, LinkedIN can be both a barrier and a facilitator to social interaction.
   4. I didn't mention this in my generic case study above, but another tool we've used in the past, is Everquest - a MMORG where Elves, Halflings, Humans, etc are wizards, warriors, bards, etc and perform quests in groups. When you have a local group of coworkers, you can all go out for lunch or supper or do some "team building" activity. How do you do this when you have users in London, Singapore, all time zones in the U.S.A., IT folk in two states and two other countries, and developers scattered about the U.S.A as well? We did it in Everquest. We're looking more at World of Warcraft for fun, and Second Life for business, as these virtual environments are more accessible from both MacOSX and Windows.
   5. I use Coppermine, an open source photo gallery, that we host ourselves. I have an iTunes account with my dot-Mac account, and a del.icio.us account, but I'm not really into sharing through them. I don't like Digg or slashdot or memeorandum. TailRank just never seemed to live up to the promise it had - though Kevin Burton is a very impassioned speaker.
7. Do you see language as a barrier for social media? Will English become the global language of the Internet? Should it?
   1. The underlying assumption to this question is that folk use social media to meet folk they don't already know. The only place that has happened to me is through being a participant in the blogosphere, especially those segments related to open source software and, well, social media. Yes, language is, and will continue to be, a very large barrier to this use of social media. Real-time translating tools would be a far better solution to any one language becoming the lingua franca of the Internet. [Have you ever noticed how much of our technology today is a direct result of the imagination of Gene Roddenberry and Robert Heinlein?]
8. Are you reading more blogs or less these days? Are you watching more online video or less these days?
   1. I'm reading fewer and fewer blogs these days. The often poor grammar and typos sometimes make the meaning indecipherable. The echo chamber effect can be overwhelming. The blogosphere is indeed a big circle with stories, sometimes important, sometimes interesting and sometimes dubious, chasing around and around. When I was taught logic in high school, one logical fallacy stood out: that of authority. Just because someone with authority says something, doesn't make it true. Ask: is it logical, ethical, moral, sensible or correct?
   2. With no disrespect intended to the "This Side of the Hill Players", I've never been a fan of amateur theatre, and I haven't seen much in the online video world to change my mind. The only ones I watch are those that Ken or Bruce [you know who you are] send out in email, and not even all of those. I've also pretty much given up on podcasts, both making them and listening to them.
9. Write a question(s) for yourself and answer it. OK, fine. What is holding back the acceptance of all these great new toys, er, tools?
   1. I think that a lot of things are holding back more general acceptance of all this new stuff to help us reach out, learn, and share.
      1. Personality: not everyone, not even the majority want to reach out to new people and new experiences. There are many areas around the world, in the U.S.A. in every country, where the people are very parochial. I'm amazed by the number of people that I've met throughout the years - though not so much in California - who live blocks away from where they grew up, have the same set of friends that they made in elementary school, and don't want anything else.
      2. Usability: many of these tools, and even computers in general, make assumptions about the user's geek-level, and they are simply too hard to use. What's intuitive for someone who has been using our very counter-intuitive computer user interface for years, is not intuitive for the general public. I've been harping since the mid-80's that touchscreens are the only basis for a truly intuitive UI. I'm very interested in seeing how the multi-touch interfaces of the Apple iPhone, Microsoft Surface, as in Minority Report and other devices, will fare in the marketplace.
      3. Infrastructure: broadband doesn't exist everywhere - not even in the Bay Area, nor does WiFi, 3G wireless, or even 2G. Actually, as I drive from the Coast to Sunnyvale, I have no signal on CA-1 or I-280 for about one-third of the trip, total. Other important issues related to infrastructure are net neutrality and carrier restrictions on what devices/software can do.
      4. Interoperability: email became the killer app because of sendmail. Not known outside of IT geekdom, this magic decoder ring of a software package allows email to flow from any type of computer to any other type of computer, along any type of network, using any type of email client software [MUA] and even any other type of mail server software [MTA]. Without it, email wouldn't be useful. I'm using b2evolution as my blogging engine, and Shel uses Typepad, but the wonders of trackback allows me to write this answer to his post on my blog, while a link and excerpt will show up in the comments on his blog. That's interoperability. Until all the software tools that call themselves some form of social media enabler can intermesh with all the others, they won't be useful. Marc Canter rants very well on his blog on this subject, and many others.
10. Additional comments?
    1. Social media has no one definition. There is a wide variety of software, technology, interdependencies and philosophies which could rally under this banner. Some of my answers, and some of those others that I've read through Shel's blog, might seem to ramble or be discussing multiple and disparate topics because of this. I see strong ties among topics like business intelligence, knowledge management, SOA, BRM, BPEL, predictive analytics, customer/vendor/partner relationship, community, offsourcing, telecommuting, presence, identity and social media. There is no such thing as deterministic behaviour in people, or nature, or systems. Everything is either chaotic or probabilistic. Catastrophe theory says to watch the inflection points. Look for the "eureka" moments, the unexpected. Look to the past, add a little Bayes, and then do it all again, learning each time. And enjoy the ride.

That would be me of course. I drove the 9 miles down the Cabrillo Highway to the Ritz of Half Moon Bay to join Robert & Patrick Scoble, Hasan Diwan [another OraAlum - hey, Hasan, are you a member?], Bud Ozborn [Bud, I removed the link I had for you, as I must have gotten it wrong - it goes to a domain sales site - my apologies] and Don MacAskill at NoFoo. Robert was live blogging over his EV-DO card - no WiFi out by the Firepit.

There were many intersting topics of conversation, which Robert has written about. One that hasn't made it onto his blog yet is about Personal Space, Public Space and the control of one's identity and data. This is central to living the TeleInterActive Lifestyle™ and so really grabbed my attention. [Pun intended.] Here are some links from or related to the conversation.

• Purse Lip Square Jaw
• Kim Cameron's Identity Blog
• Marc Canter
• PeopleAggregator
• Structured Blogging
• Identity Woman
• Identity2.0
• Attention Trust

It was a very interesting afternoon. Just what I needed after my earlier frustrations: great geeky conversation, campari and soda, and sushi.

I've been sending and receiving email "on the go" for well over five years. My solutions have always involved the PalmOS. I've never had to resort to a "redirector" from my desktop/laptop email client. There are a variety of approaches to mobile and wireless email. Daniel Taylor speaks to the solutions and ongoing problems in "Mobile e-mail solutions for small business".

Small businesses often have the edge here over large and even medium sized businesses. They can control the email service they use. Businesses that rely solely on using a Microsoft Exchange Server, or other proprietary collaboration server such as Lotus Notes, with that server located behind a firewall face the toughest challenge. The email services can be set up so that the proprietary collaboration server is only part of the package, with the standard protocols SMTP, POP3 and IMAP4 being part of the mix as well.

The first mobile email I had was way back in 1994 [pre-Palm] at Oracle using either Oracle Office Disconnected Client or Oracle Mobile Agents. Oralce's Collaboration Suite still serves up fully synchronized email to a wide variety of devices.

Synchronization for "casually connected" clients is also one, albeit asynchronous, solution, and even the earliest Palm software allowed synch'g your inbox, read, respond and compose offline, and synch again later. Not great if you want near "real time" information exchange.

The solution that I use now is the best I've ever had. In addition to our consulting services, we've started a hosting service, the TeleInterActive Networks. We provide IMAP4 email. This is great for multiple email clients from wireless connectivity to your favorite desktop email client, through in a laptop, and even webmail from a convenient Internet Café they are always synchronized through the IMAP server: inbox, sent email, even critical "saved" folders can all be sync'd. I can even get attachments and read them on my Palm.

Though this does get me back to a pet peeve of mine. Since email became the killer app for the Internet and is still the most used application, we've kludged everything possible onto it. eMail was never meant to send files and is not secure. Even today, email

• attachments can't always be read,
• take effort to remove from the email, if your email client can even do this
• looses the chain of delivery when you do detach an attachment
• is painful to encrypt or otherwise make secure, and thus,
• is rarely used securely

There are far better collaboration tools than email. But I'm getting off topic. If you do want to use email wirelessly, take a look at the services that Dan cites to extend MS Exchange beyond the firewall. Or, consider a hosting service that will give you IMAP email with enough storage space to keep your current attachments to hand.

We prefer hosting our own wiki(survey) software, vs. using a third-party or using email. There are two good open source survey software packages: phpESP and PHP Surveyor. We chose phpESP for our purposes. There are four potential advantages to hosting your own software, if you can:

1. The survey is up if your blog site is up with no additional lag time
2. Some users may not be willing to follow an "off site" link
3. You have the advantage of understanding and controlling the underlying statistical manipulations
4. The survey will have the same look as your site

Email surveys may be ignored, or treated as spam. We've found that if folk are at your site, they will be more willing to complete a survey on your site than respond to an email survey.

Both phpESP and PHP Surveyor are written in PHP and use a MySQL database. They both allow you to format the public [presentation] areas of the survey using CSS templates. Both also allow you to export your survey results to CSV so that you can analyze the results in a spreadsheet such as Excel, though phpESP offers internal statistical analysis and presentation of results without exporting, including cross analysis and cross tabulation. PHP Surveyor has more predefined quesiton types, though phpESP gets there with increased flexibility. phpESP has gotten good reviews on its ease of use and statistical rigour. As soon as we free up some time, we'll subject both to Bernard Golden's Open Source Maturity Model and see how they compare.

Jacqueline Mackie Paisley Passey is looking for software to conduct a survey concerning blogging for her ECON 475 Econometrics class. We hope this information helps you. Let us know if you need anything in this area.

Apple is adding feed syndication podcatcher capability to iTunes. This served as a central theme for the return of the Gillmor Gang on May 28th. As a tangent to the converstaion, the Gang discussed the ability - or lack thereof - of the Apple iPod to take full advantage of RSSv1, RSSv2 and Atom feed syndication. Of course, the iPod has no OS/API/applications to do this.

"Looking at other implications of the iTunes announcement. Doesn't this also mean that with RSS, that the iPod is much further along in it's being the total multipurpose device? You know... What's to say that you wouldn't be able to, on the disk, have all the things that you might subscribe to via RSS, in that device and you might then plug into headphones or into a TV screen? Well..."

-- Steve Gillmor, Jon Udell, Dana Gardner, Mike Vizard, and Doc Searls, with guest Adam Curry and Executive Producer Doug Kaye Gillmor Gang Rides Again 33m:44s - 35m:06s

No doubt the iPod is great, but its main job is to play m4p files. If you want the ability to grab your feeds no matter the media, how about the Palm Lifedrive or one of these from the Daily Wireless article "WiFi MP3 Players". So, forget the iPod and get a machine that let's you get to all your feeds, podcast, songs, blogs, vlogs, news, and whatever comes next.